I've read many claims from either side of the debate around fracking (hydraulic fracturing to extract fossil fuels) that the process is either bad for local groundwater contamination or safe, as suggested by the EPA or prominent politicians. Can water & environment experts please answer & explain a bit more if fracking is safe for water resources? Thanks.
No Consensus Yet
Expert consensus not reached
6 more experts needed to answer
Greg Goss has answered Likely
An expert from University of Alberta in Toxicology, Hydrology
This is a quite complex process and perhaps not simple question and answer. "Fracking" is the process to break up the rock and release hydrocarbons. This process is the same as a "conventional" oil and gas well except for the ~week-long process to "stimulate" the well to make more oil flow using water that is pressurized. To encourage the well staying open, they add a fine sand (called a proppant) plus a mixture of chemicals. There is not "thousands" of chemicals as some claim, usually a mixture might contain 8-20 different additives that are are different for each well.
Most often, the drilling is a mile or more below and under many layers of rock, in these cases, and with new drilling techniques and well management, "fracking" has very low potential to contaminate groundwater for drinking water supplies. What happens after the well starts to produce is that a mix of water and oil and gas comes back, is separated and the oil/gas recovered. The remaining oil contaminated waste water has high salinity (salt), high oils plus a lot of metals and what ever is left from the chemicals put down there. In most places, this water is re-injected back down in another area (called a disposal well) and they inject it back 1-3 miles below ground. However, in a small but significant number of cases, something goes wrong such as a well casing cracking or a surface spills of the wastewater and the wastewater escapes where it can get into drinking water (either a river, lake or shallow groundwater). In some jurisdictions in US for example, they allow "fracking"wastewater to be applied to roads while in others, they allow it to be released to rivers, something I think needs to stop.
So the short answer is yes, it can be bad for drinking water, but normally/usually is not. If the oil and gas reserves are shallow, the potential for these chemicals to contaminate the groundwater increases. However, if the companies are using the more advanced water management techniques, more recent well design and monitoring techniques, and following proper disposal of wastes, "fracking" is as safe as most other industrial processes we allow (manufacturing releases, pesticides etc) and should not be a huge concern relative to the other risks we face.
Answered about 7 years ago
Did this expert answer help you?
We rely on donors and members to keep trusted facts flowing freely for everyone. So we ask if you have learnt new knowledge from our community or like the idea of an independent fact-checking platform powered by science, you can support Metafact for as little as $2.
Support MetafactLoading...