No Consensus Yet
Expert consensus not reached
4 more experts needed to answer
Reinhold Vieth has answered Extremely Unlikely
An expert from University of Toronto in Nutrition, Vitamins
NO. Human bodies possess a factory that makes vitamin D; it is called the skin. Winter clothing shuts down 95% of that factory (face and hands is only 5% of skin surface). Beyond that, a rule of thumb is that you need the sun to be at least 45 degrees above the horizon (a UV index of at least 3) for it to provide the skin of a white person enough ultraviolet light to make a useful amount of vitamin D.
Bear in mind that skin pigmentation acts like a sunblock, so that a very dark-skin person has the equivalent of SPF 6 sunscreen naturally built into their skin, and needs six times as much ultraviolet light (a combination of sun intensity and/or exposure time) to make the same amount of vitamin D sdas a White person. All populations outside the tropics exhibit declining levels of vitamin D nutrition during winter months. Fortunately, vitamin D disappears slowly out of the body, so our summer gain in vitamin D helps to prevent severe deficiency during winter. The prudent thing is to keep supplementing with vitamin D all year.
Answered over 4 years ago
Did this expert answer help you?
We rely on donors and members to keep trusted facts flowing freely for everyone. So we ask if you have learnt new knowledge from our community or like the idea of an independent fact-checking platform powered by science, you can support Metafact for as little as $2.
Support MetafactLoading...
Dr Reinhold Vieth is a
Emeritus Professor in
the Department of
Nutritional Sciences,
and the Department
of Laboratory
Medicine and
Pathobio... Read more