A news report suggests tardigrade (water bears) to be the most resilient animal ever. Can experts/evolutionary biologists confirm this please. Thanks
Affirmative
From 8 verified experts:
5 answered Likely or higher
Doc Roc has answered Likely
An expert from McMaster University in Evolutionary Biology, Astrobiology
the answer to that question, of course, depends on what is intended by ‘indestructible’
tardigrades exhibit amazing resilience, arguably the most-impressive among animals
studies reporting surviving in a desiccated, ametabolic state for a century (contested) or in a frozen state for 30 years (uncontested) are remarkable
some data about tolerance to some ‘destructive’ factors are presented immediately below in point-form
· desiccation: specimens in some species can be dehydrated, losing essentially all water, with reanimation following rehydration
· radiation: 5000 Gy gamma radiation (the radiation type that, in the Marvel Universe, transformed David Banner into the Incredible Hulk; for reference, 1 Gy = one joule radiation energy per kilogram; 5-10 Gy kills humans)
· temperature (low & high): -273 ØC (dehydrated) and -253 ØC (hydrated, for 35 minutes) have been reported but -180 ØC (dehydrated, 14 days) definitely is possible & 110-151 ØC (30 minutes)
· specimens have been sent into orbit aboard spacecraft, showing tolerance to extreme conditions (vacuum, low temperature, high radiation) with extents determined by combinations (e.g., vacuum & temperature shielded from radiation, etc.) but surviving nevertheless
all these data are conditioned on the fact that only 1-2% among the 1400 species have been ‘tested’ experimentally; tolerance depends on multiple factors (including the state in which individuals are tested – e.g., hydrated or dehydrated – and usually only one extreme factor is tested in an experiment); and, of course, active individuals must eat to persist (i.e., specimens could be ‘destroyed’ through starvation)
Answered over 4 years ago
Did this expert answer help you?
We rely on donors and members to keep trusted facts flowing freely for everyone. So we ask if you have learnt new knowledge from our community or like the idea of an independent fact-checking platform powered by science, you can support Metafact for as little as $2.
Support MetafactLoading...